Today, I saw the Smiffenpoofs (A Capella group from all-women's Smith College) and the IC Voice Stream (from yes, Ithaca College) perform for 2ish hours in front of a shiny backdrop.
The Smiffs
The Smiffs were SMOOTH, if there was one word to describe them. Turns out, the Smiffs are the first official collegiate A Capella group to grace the US stage. Their ensemble sounded as if there was one big, multi-timbred vocalist on each part, if that makes any sense. They shone when it was just the full chorus singing; each part mixed into the other, with rising and falling pitches that made a quite, soothing symphony.
They had excellent beatboxers, with a rock solid internal group tempo and synergy. However, during solos, the entire group seemed to lose it's edge. Perhaps due to the sound system, or perhaps because of something else, soloists in this ensemble never stood out. Their rap wasn't fantastic either; most of the laughs came from the extreme sense of irony... but hey! They got us to laugh. And clap during songs, and whoop and holler. So, they engaged their audience... BUT...
Voice Stream
Not as much as ICVS. Partly due to the energized Ithaca College crowd present, and partly due to a more upbeat selection of repertoire, ICVS made a visceral impact on the audience.
Soloists, although mixed too low, were intense and open, giving themselves up to the crowds scrutiny. The group is fairly large, and builds to climaxes brilliantly; it's sense of rhythm is impeccable. Tight hits and holds and pauses and harmonies.
Even with all this praise about the ensemble's synthesis, individual voices did not blend very well. It seemed like everyone was in chest voice, which is where voices are usually most distinct. There was rarely a perfect blend, where it was a single chorus of voice.
Direction
The show's lighting was nice. Simple, effective, pretty. The sound could have been AWESOME, particularly since they had three choir mics and some trusted SM-58s. But the mix was poorly done. There was little separation between the solos and ensemble, perhaps resulting in the low solo performances mentioned above. The choral mix could have used a bit of stereo separation as well, since the room proved itself to be stereo by having random loss of sound on the left channel occasionally. And the mic stands should have been gaff taped to the ground, so one didn't have to fall on the Smiffs!
Lessons
- Don't play with your cell phone during a show; even if you have a dark theme, it's distracting.
- Don't get up during a performance. Even when the group was really engaging, a single person standing up or walking around in the audience caught my eyes.
- Gaff tape everything in life.
- If you're blogging on a performance, find out where to buy merch and post that with the blog, instead of ignoring it :(